Broker: CMHC should not insure collateral charges

Government interference in the mortgage industry has a history of frustrating brokers, but one leading player believes CMHC changes could be the key to reining in collateral charge mortgages.

“Collateral charges are registered against a person’s credit rating, like a loan. So therefore it should not be covered under the CMHC; a mortgage is a mortgage and is a shared interest in a property – it should not be treated as a loan,” Omer Quenneville of Centum Regal Financial told“So if a bank chooses to do this to protect their interest then they should have to forego the CMHC protection, in my opinion; CMHC isn’t there to protect loans.”

The positives and negatives of collateral charges tied to mortgages have been debated ad nauseam by mortgage brokers and the latest was spawned by a CBC investigation about the lack of disclosure one big bank provides for these products.

And according to Quenneville, the government should not be insuring a product that, in his opinion, is meant to protect big bank interests.

“It has very little do with protecting the customers’ interest and by putting a collateral charge on a property it enables banks to do all kinds of things including collections on other debts by using that collateral charge,” Quenneville said. “And it even shows up on a person’s credit rating whereas a traditional mortgage will not show up because it’s not a loan, it’s a shared interest.”

But would collateral charge mortgage products become less common if CMHC refuses to insure them?

“Absolutely, I think they would be much less prevalent if CMHC refused to insure collateral charges,” Quenneville said.

Stephen Hall

Stephen Hall

Affiliated Real Estate Agent
CENTURY 21 Seller's Choice Inc.
Contact Me

Blog Archives